Private money loans in St. Augustine.
A direct lender for St. Augustine investors, open every hour of every day. First position only, with an owner on every file.
The St. Augustine market
St. Augustine is the oldest continuously occupied European-founded city in the United States, and tourism is constant. Around it, St. Johns County has been one of the fastest-growing counties in Florida, known for its schools and for large master-planned communities.
What the housing looks like
The historic city has homes spanning three centuries, with Lincolnville and the neighborhoods near downtown full of Victorian and early twentieth-century houses. West Augustine has modest older homes. The northern county is almost all new construction.
What investors do here
Vacation rentals near the historic district and the beaches are a major draw. Careful renovations of older homes sell well. In the growing parts of the county, builders work small parcels.
How old the homes are in St. Augustine
The colonial core dates from the 1700s, with coquina and frame buildings rebuilt and added to through the 1800s. Henry Flagler's hotels in the 1880s brought the Model Land tract west of the plaza, and Lincolnville, founded after the Civil War, filled with frame houses from the 1880s through the 1920s. North City, Fullerwood and Nelmar Terrace are mostly from the 1910s to the 1940s. Davis Shores on Anastasia Island was laid out in the 1920s boom but built mainly in the 1950s and 1960s. St. Augustine Beach and St. Augustine South followed from the 1950s through the 1970s, St. Augustine Shores in the 1970s and 1980s, and the northern county after 2000. Old-city houses are wood frame on piers with metal roofs. Mid-century houses are block on slabs at low elevation.
What we look at on a St. Augustine deal
The city’s historic preservation rules are among the strictest in Florida, and exterior work in the historic districts needs approval. Short-term rentals require registration and face limits in some zones. Low-lying streets in the old city flood during storms and very high tides.
We raise these things in the first conversation so they never become a surprise three weeks in. It is part of why a term sheet from us is one we expect to close.
St. Augustine hot spots.
The established areas investors compete for, and what each one suits.
- Lincolnville
- A National Register district south of King Street with frame houses from the 1880s through the 1920s, a short walk from downtown. Restored houses sell and rent well, and the low streets near Maria Sanchez Lake need a flood check.
- Historic downtown and the HP districts
- The colonial city and the Flagler-era blocks beside it. Properties rarely trade and every exterior change goes before the review board, so projects here suit patient owners with experience in old buildings.
- Uptown and North City
- The neighborhoods along San Marco Avenue north of the fort, including Fullerwood and Nelmar Terrace. Bungalows and frame houses from the 1910s through the 1940s draw buyers who want older character on somewhat higher ground.
- Davis Shores
- Block ranch homes from the 1950s and 1960s just across the Bridge of Lions. Demand is strong because of the location, and the central issue on every house is how high it sits and whether it has been elevated.
- St. Augustine Beach
- A separate city on Anastasia Island with cottages, newer homes and condominiums from the 1970s onward. Vacation rental demand is steady, but transient rental licenses are limited to certain land use categories and capped in the residential one.
- St. Augustine South and the Shores
- County subdivisions south of the city off US 1, built from the 1950s through the 1980s. Block construction and the absence of historic review make this the area's plain renovation and long-term rental market.
Up-and-coming areas.
Places investors are watching, and the reason each one is changing.
- West Augustine
- An unincorporated area west of the city with modest older houses and vacant lots. It is a county redevelopment area, and sewer and water do not reach every street. Confirm with the county utility what serves each parcel, and check its title.
- West City and West King Street
- The city created a redevelopment area here in 2024 and adopted its long-range plan in 2025. The plan is funded from growth in the area's property tax base, so public improvements will come gradually.
- Vilano Beach
- The county has a redevelopment plan for the town center near the bridge, and older cottages on the surrounding streets are being replaced with elevated homes. County short-term rental registration applies here, east of the Intracoastal Waterway.
- State Road 207 and State Road 16 corridors
- New subdivisions and apartments have been filling the land between the city and Interstate 95. Small builders work the leftover parcels, where county impact fees and drainage are the main budget items.
Things to take into consideration.
- Most exterior work in the city's five HP zoning districts needs a certificate of appropriateness from the Historic Architectural Review Board, judged against the city's architectural guidelines. Board calendars set the pace, so the approval comes before the construction schedule.
- Anywhere in the city, fully demolishing a structure fifty years or older requires a demolition certificate, and removing historic exterior features can require one too. A plan that depends on taking down an old addition should be checked first.
- St. Augustine has an archaeology ordinance. Before digging for a foundation, pool or utility line, ask the planning department whether the lot is in an archaeological zone and what review the work needs, and put that time in the schedule.
- Hurricane Matthew in 2016 and Hurricane Irma in 2017 flooded downtown, Lincolnville and Davis Shores. Northeasters and very high tides also put water in the low streets, and the city has drainage and backflow projects under way.
- Short-term rental rules differ among the City of St. Augustine, the City of St. Augustine Beach and unincorporated St. Johns County. The same house plan can be a nightly rental, a weekly rental or neither, depending on the address.
- The city requires an on-site parking space for each bedroom of a short-term rental unless the planning board approves an alternative. Many old-city lots are too narrow to provide it, which limits the bedrooms that can be registered.
- St. Johns County charges substantial impact fees on new homes, and lots in the master-planned communities often carry community development district assessments on the tax bill. Both affect what a builder nets and what a rental has to cover.
Every loan we make in St. Augustine.
- Fix and flip
Purchase and rehab in one first-position loan, with the rehab paid out in draws as the work gets done.
Fix and flip in St. Augustine - New construction
Lot and vertical construction in one first-position loan for spec homes, infill and build-to-rent.
New construction in St. Augustine - Mid-construction
A first-position refinance for a project already under construction, with funds to finish it.
Mid-construction in St. Augustine - Bridge
Short-term first-position money to buy, refinance or pull cash out while the long-term plan comes together.
Bridge in St. Augustine - DSCR rental
Long-term first-position rental financing qualified on the property’s income, with no tax returns.
DSCR rental in St. Augustine - Portfolio
One first-position loan across several rental properties, for purchase, refinance or cash out.
Portfolio in St. Augustine - Commercial
First-position bridge financing for multifamily, mixed-use, retail, office and light industrial property.
Commercial in St. Augustine
Where we lend around St. Augustine.
- Lincolnville
- West Augustine
- St. Augustine Beach
- Vilano Beach
- Ponte Vedra
- Nocatee
- Palm Coast
Other markets in Northeast Florida
St. Augustine questions.
Does Think Private Lending make hard money loans in St. Augustine?
Yes. We make first-position fix and flip, new construction, mid-construction, bridge, DSCR rental, portfolio and commercial loans on investment property in St. Augustine and across St. Johns County.
How do I get a loan started on a St. Augustine property?
Send the address, the price, the budget and the finished value at any hour. An owner reviews every file, and you will get a term sheet we expect to close or a clear no with the reason.
Do you offer second mortgages or gap funding in St. Augustine?
No. We lend in first position only, everywhere we lend.